Reviews
palmOne
Zire 31
Unlike the Zire or Zire 21, the new 31 offers the most bang
for the buck of any Palm device before it
Congratulations
to palmOne for creating a low-end Zire that's really worth carrying.
The Zire 31 is the first color Palm device that truly keeps to
the credo of cheaper, faster, smaller, lighter, smarter, and longer÷battery
life, that is. Indeed, it's the first low-end Zire that I'd recommend
to someone like my mother or sisters: people who think such a
device might be useful for them, but don't want to lay out the
money necessary for a Zire 71 or 72 so they can find out. Unlike
the Zire and Zire 21, the Zire 31 offers the most bang-per-buck
of any Palm device before it. I wasn't terribly enthusiastic about
either of its predecessors, but that changes with the Zire 31.
I keep thinking, ãEmergency backup device.ä It even makes me think
of ditching my T3 and taking a simpler route, if you can believe
that. Between you and me, that is saying something.
On first inspection,
the Zire 31 is little different from its forebears. Its body consists
of a white plastic back shell and a blue plastic front shell.
Simple. Across the top is a dark translucent plastic piece that
caps it off; its translucency, though not apparent, is important,
because of the infra-red port that resides here. The 31 is still
light, at 4.1 ounces with the flip cover. Its smooth tapered back
sits comfortably in the hand. Flip open its rubbery blue lid and
it often flips right back. I generally remove it for this reason.
On the back, you see one of the 31's newest features: six holes
for a real mono speaker, one that not only beeps but also plays
music.
On the left
side is a rubber door, borrowed from the world of digital cameras.
Pull it open and you'll find that while it pulls out a little,
it's tethered permanently to the body. The USB and power jacks
are behind this cover, far better placed than they were on the
top of the older Zires. On top are the 3.5mm audio jack, SD card
slot, and stylus silo. And somewhere behind that shiny plastic
is the IrDA port. The SD card slot gets a nice high-end feature,
a spring-loaded door to keep out dust.
The rest of
the action is on the ãZindigo Blueä front panel. Keeping with
low-end Zire tradition, the 31 has only two application buttons:
Date Book and Contacts. A little sophistication is added with
the 5-way navigator in the center. Now all current palmOne handhelds
have the 5-way, a menu/program navigation system that's becoming
standard on all manner of digital devices, including digital cameras.
The
standard static Graffiti 2 pad has one change, a HotSync icon.
This is a better idea than making new users hunt through the Applications
window for this important icon.
Hit the power
button and a whole new range of change is visible. All of the
enhancements made to the basic applications on the palmOne Tungsten
T3 and E are now available on the Zire 31, plus some new features.
The first one you see is the ability to place pictures in the
background of the Applications and Agenda view. You can even fade
the pictures out so that you can both see your favorite picture
and read the names that accompany the icons better. You can categorize
Date Book entries using colors, displaying only the relevant ones,
and export categories to other handhelds so that your partner
can track your schedule. Photos can be embedded into Contacts
entries. This was possible long ago with Sony CLIEs, but this
special palmOne application requires no link to an external database,
and the original file need not remain on the device: the photos
are now included in the Contacts data file.
Using the
5-way navigator, it's easy to jump around in applications, pressing
the middle button to enter a list, then the four sides of the
navigator to move around through lists and icons. Just about everything
can be opened and browsed without taking out the stylus, an improvement
worth noting.
For text entry,
the Zire 31 defaults to Graffiti 2. Using an application like
TealScript, you can restore old Graffiti if you prefer. The 31's
200Mhz StrongARM processor is more than capable of handling the
extra work.
Yes, 200Mhz
is the speed of the processor on this low-end device. It also
has 16MB RAM onboard, of which 14 are available. The SD slot means
this new device is capable of just about everything most need
a Palm device to do, including music playback. The bundled RealOne
Player software plays MP3 songs from an SD card with ease. It's
best to use headphones, but the built-in speaker is a respectable
music maker in a quiet room or office. No, it's not stereo, and
it doesn't thump, but it's decent for what it is. With headphones
on, you don't know the difference from any other MP3 player.
The greatest
limitation of past low-end Zire offerings has been the 160 x 160
monochrome screen. For some, it's a more versatile solution, because
it works for text both indoors and out. I agree that this is important.
But to be honest, most handhelds are used indoors in dim light,
and what the monochrome Zires lacked was a backlight of any kind.
Users were forced to find good lighting and angle their handheld
to gather the most they could. Putting a color screen into the
Zire 31 makes this low-cost handheld more accessible to its most
common users. To those of us who've already gotten used to the
brilliant 320 x 320 screens of our higher-end Palm devices, the
Zire 31 screen appears blotchy and grainy, and the fonts jaggy.
But to those used to an older device, the screen really is decent.
It has a blue-white background, and its colors are bright. palmOne
says the screen has ãthousands of colors.ä That's probably true,
just not 64K colors as we see on the more expensive devices. As
a result, photos aren't perfect, but you can tell who you're looking
at in most shots. The screen on some colors will flicker or sparkle,
likely due to the changing of pixels between slightly different
colors. This is the method the 31 uses to simulate greater color
depth.
This is no
TFT screen, either, but an older-style STN (super-twist nematic)
display. As such it doesn't work well in direct sunlight. You
can squint and look something up in a pinch, which is better than
previous designs, but I wouldn't suggest reading a book outdoors
in sunlight. Shade is passable. Action games are also out of the
question. The STN display just doesn't respond fast enough, and
fast moving ships, bullets, and cars look like blurry ghosts that
will attack you before you see them in some cases. Expect to stick
with puzzle games like Bejeweled and you'll be happy.
Right out
of the box, the Zire 31 is able to do almost everything most users
will need. The only exception is MP3 playback, which will require
purchase of an SD card. Get yourself at least a 128MB card to
reasonably enjoy this feature. This size will hold up to four
albums worth of songs, depending on the compression ratio you
choose. When I compress to 128K, I can get two full albums on
a 128MB card. Another audio product bundled with the Zire 31 is
Audible Player. Audible is a subscription service that allows
you to download audio books to your computer that you then sync
to your handheld device. You can listen to them with headphones
or plug the handheld into your car stereo with a cassette adapter
or one of the line-in jacks available on more car stereos.
PalmReader
allows you to download books in a simpler but no less powerful
format: text. It's surprisingly easy to read a book on a Palm
device. Text reads more like a newspaper column than a book, and
the PalmReader application can even scroll the text for you as
you read. Two books are included for free: Last of the Mohicans
and the Wonderful Wizard of Oz. 
Others
are available for free or pay from the Palm Digital Media website.
Other bundled
applications include the Photos application, which allows you
to sync photos from your desktop computer. You can also receive
photos beamed from other handhelds, like the Zire 71 or 72 and
immediately display them on your device. The other obvious source
is any digital camera that uses an SD card for image storage.
Probably the most played game in computer history is Solitaire
for Windows, and that's included as well, only in a Palm version.
If you like the Windows version, you'll waste hours with this
one; only now you can waste them wherever you are.
I'm continually
surprised by how much I like the Zire 31, especially considering
how little I liked the past models. They sufficed, but only badly
embodied some of what we liked about Palms back in the day, but
this model could meet most of my needs for a handheld device÷if
I weren't so dependent on the concept of email everywhere as I
am with my Tungsten T3. Still, email isn't everything, and if
you're looking for a simple handheld that is light and easy to
use, with a great battery life (measured in weeks if little-used),
the Zire 31 is an excellent choice. If you're looking for a first
handheld for afriend, spouse, mom, or child, the Zire 31 is ideal.
Most newcomers don't need wireless; and if they ever do, IrDA
is built right in for email and Web access via a great many modern
cell phones. For US$150 it's tough to beat.
÷Shawn Barnett
Home
